top of page

US Justice Department can use military lawyers to prosecute civilians, judge rules

The Trump administration's assignment of military lawyers to help the Department of Justice prosecute civilians for offenses unrelated to the military does not violate federal law, a Minnesota judge ruled on Friday.

Nate Raymond/Reuters

FILE PHOTO: A new banner depicting U.S. President Donald Trump is put up on the Department of Justice building in Washington, D.C., U.S., February 20, 2026.

Ken Cedeno/Reuters

The Trump administration's assignment of military lawyers to help the Department of Justice prosecute civilians for offenses unrelated to the military does not violate federal law, a Minnesota judge ruled on Friday.


U.S. Magistrate Judge Shannon Elkins in Minneapolis reached that conclusion in a closely watched case in which a defendant challenged the lawfulness of being prosecuted by a lawyer from the armed services.


Paul Johnson, a Minnesota resident, was charged with assaulting a Customs and Border Protection agent in January as President Donald Trump's administration pursued an aggressive immigration enforcement surge in his state.


During the surge, the Defense Department assigned lawyers belonging to the Judge Advocate General's Corps to assist the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota, after it had sent JAGs to help prosecute crime in Washington, D.C., and Tennessee.


Lawyers for Johnson argued that the use of JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians in cases without a military nexus violated the Posse Comitatus Act, an 1878 law that generally forbids the military from taking part in civilian law enforcement, as well as Department of Defense regulations.


He sought to have the military lawyer removed from his case, a cause that garnered national attention after 11 former JAG lawyers filed a brief supporting him that argued "the government has crossed a perilous line."


But Elkins sided with the government in finding that Congress had through two other laws created exceptions to the Posse Comitatus Act that give the U.S. attorney general the authority to appoint JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians as special assistant U.S. attorneys.


"If Congress passes statutes giving the Department of Justice the authority to appoint active military personnel as SAUSAs to prosecute civilians, that is the law," she wrote.


She said that while Defense Department regulations recognize it would be "ill-advised" for JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians in cases unrelated to the military, those regulations do not give her the power to disqualify a military lawyer from Johnson's case.


Kevin Riach, a lawyer for Johnson, said he plans to appeal. Representatives for the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota did not respond to requests for comment.


-Nate Raymond in Boston; Editing by William Mallard/Reuters

The Trump administration's assignment of military lawyers to help the Department of Justice prosecute civilians for offenses unrelated to the military does not violate federal law, a Minnesota judge ruled on Friday.


U.S. Magistrate Judge Shannon Elkins in Minneapolis reached that conclusion in a closely watched case in which a defendant challenged the lawfulness of being prosecuted by a lawyer from the armed services.


Paul Johnson, a Minnesota resident, was charged with assaulting a Customs and Border Protection agent in January as President Donald Trump's administration pursued an aggressive immigration enforcement surge in his state.


During the surge, the Defense Department assigned lawyers belonging to the Judge Advocate General's Corps to assist the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota, after it had sent JAGs to help prosecute crime in Washington, D.C., and Tennessee.


Lawyers for Johnson argued that the use of JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians in cases without a military nexus violated the Posse Comitatus Act, an 1878 law that generally forbids the military from taking part in civilian law enforcement, as well as Department of Defense regulations.


He sought to have the military lawyer removed from his case, a cause that garnered national attention after 11 former JAG lawyers filed a brief supporting him that argued "the government has crossed a perilous line."


But Elkins sided with the government in finding that Congress had through two other laws created exceptions to the Posse Comitatus Act that give the U.S. attorney general the authority to appoint JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians as special assistant U.S. attorneys.


"If Congress passes statutes giving the Department of Justice the authority to appoint active military personnel as SAUSAs to prosecute civilians, that is the law," she wrote.


She said that while Defense Department regulations recognize it would be "ill-advised" for JAG lawyers to prosecute civilians in cases unrelated to the military, those regulations do not give her the power to disqualify a military lawyer from Johnson's case.


Kevin Riach, a lawyer for Johnson, said he plans to appeal. Representatives for the U.S. Attorney's Office in Minnesota did not respond to requests for comment.


-Nate Raymond in Boston; Editing by William Mallard/Reuters

TOP POLITICAL STORIES

Add a Title

Start Now

Add a Title

Start Now

Add a Title

Start Now
US approves military sales of over $8.6 billion to Middle East allies

US approves military sales of over $8.6 billion to Middle East allies

Start Now
US Justice Department can use military lawyers to prosecute civilians, judge rules

US Justice Department can use military lawyers to prosecute civilians, judge rules

Start Now
Trump: US Navy acting 'like pirates' to carry out naval blockade of Iranian ports

Trump: US Navy acting 'like pirates' to carry out naval blockade of Iranian ports

Start Now

LATEST NEWS

Add a Title

Start Now

Add a Title

Start Now

Add a Title

Start Now
At least 11 dead in western Mexico after bus careens off highway

At least 11 dead in western Mexico after bus careens off highway

Start Now
Man convicted of attempting terrorist attack at London's Israeli embassy

Man convicted of attempting terrorist attack at London's Israeli embassy

Start Now
Large fire in Tuscany forces evacuation of around 3,000 people

Large fire in Tuscany forces evacuation of around 3,000 people

Start Now

PARALUMAN NEWS

© 2025 Paraluman News Publication

bottom of page